TLDR: TangledFeatures is a new framework for feature selection that excels in datasets with highly correlated predictors. It identifies representative features from groups of entangled variables, reducing redundancy while maintaining explanatory power and interpretability. Demonstrated on Alanine Dipeptide, it shows competitive predictive accuracy, superior stability, and selects biologically meaningful features, offering a robust approach for reproducible research in structural biology.
In the world of machine learning and scientific discovery, selecting the right features for a model is crucial. It impacts not only how well a model predicts outcomes but also how easily we can understand why it makes those predictions. However, many existing methods struggle when features are highly correlated, leading to unstable and difficult-to-interpret results. This is a significant challenge, especially in fields like structural biology where understanding the underlying drivers of biological processes is paramount.
Addressing this critical gap, researchers have introduced a novel framework called TangledFeatures. This innovative approach is designed specifically for feature selection in spaces where predictors are highly correlated, aiming to identify representative features from groups of ‘entangled’ predictors. The goal is to reduce redundancy while preserving the explanatory power of the features, ultimately providing a more interpretable and stable foundation for analysis compared to traditional techniques.
The Need for Stable and Interpretable Features
For features to be truly meaningful in scientific contexts, they must meet two key criteria: biological interpretability and reproducibility. Interpretability means that the features should map back to known structural or functional elements, making scientific sense. Reproducibility ensures that these features consistently emerge across different analyses, rather than being mere reflections of noise or model instability. Achieving these goals is vital for building scientific trust and enabling actionable insights, such as designing new proteins or understanding disease mechanisms.
Existing methods often fall short in these areas. Post-hoc methods, which explain models after they are trained, can be unstable when features are highly correlated and may not always yield biologically meaningful drivers. Pre-hoc approaches, which design interpretable feature spaces before modeling, have also shown instability, with different runs frequently producing divergent feature sets. TangledFeatures tackles this by placing feature stability at the core of its design, ensuring that identified drivers are both interpretable and reproducible.
How TangledFeatures Works
TangledFeatures operates through a three-stage pipeline:
1. Correlation Module: This initial step identifies groups of highly correlated features. It constructs a graph where features are nodes, and an edge exists between two features if their correlation exceeds a user-defined threshold. Connected components in this graph represent clusters of features that convey largely redundant information.
2. Selection Module: For each identified cluster of correlated features, this module selects a single representative distance. It uses an ensemble-based stability selection procedure, training multiple random forests. In each run, one candidate distance is sampled from each cluster and evaluated alongside all uncorrelated variables. The distance with the highest average importance score within its cluster is chosen as the representative. This ensemble approach helps reduce variance and ensures consistent selection.
3. Refinement Module: After selecting cluster representatives, a final Random Forest feature selection step is applied. Features are ranked by their importance scores, and only those are retained until their cumulative importance reaches 99%. This ensures a compact set of distances that captures the vast majority of the predictive signal while discarding minimally contributing variables.
Demonstrating Effectiveness on Alanine Dipeptide
To validate its effectiveness, TangledFeatures was applied to Alanine Dipeptide, a widely used benchmark in structural biology. The framework was used to predict backbone torsional angles (phi and psi) using intra-atomic distances as input features. The performance was evaluated across three key axes: predictive accuracy, stability, and interpretability.
In terms of predictive accuracy, TangledFeatures remained competitive with other popular feature selection methods like LASSO and Elastic Net Regularization. While some methods might achieve slightly higher accuracy by leveraging redundant features, TangledFeatures deliberately trades a minor loss in accuracy for a significantly more stable and non-redundant feature set. This demonstrates that a compact, interpretable subset can be obtained without a substantial compromise in predictive power.
The framework truly shines in stability. When compared to methods like Elastic Net and Random Forest Recursive Feature Evaluation, TangledFeatures consistently achieved higher overlap of the most important features across multiple analyses. This indicates that the selected feature subsets are nearly identical across different data samples, and the relative ordering of feature importance is highly reproducible. This robustness is crucial for scientific trust and reproducibility.
Perhaps most importantly, TangledFeatures excels in interpretability. The features selected by the framework consistently aligned with known backbone and near-backbone interactions in the Alanine Dipeptide structure. These are interactions that structural biologists recognize as key determinants of torsional variability. In contrast, other methods like LASSO often selected redundant or chemically less meaningful distances, limiting their interpretability despite achieving compactness. This alignment with structural biology knowledge underscores the framework’s ability to produce biologically meaningful insights.
Also Read:
- Quantifying Uncertainty in Machine Learning for High-Stakes Applications
- Foundation Models: Charting a New Course for Scientific Exploration
A New Path for Reproducible Research
TangledFeatures offers a principled and novel approach to feature selection, particularly valuable in datasets with structured correlations among predictors. While simpler methods like Principal Component Analysis (PCA) or LASSO might suffice when predictive accuracy is the sole objective, TangledFeatures provides a powerful solution for reconciling interpretability with robustness. It ensures that feature selection truly reflects the informational diversity of the data, supporting reproducible research in structural biology and beyond.
For those interested in exploring this framework further, the authors have made a reproducible R package, also named TangledFeatures, available on GitHub and prepared for CRAN submission. This open availability aims to encourage adoption by researchers and practitioners seeking interpretable and redundancy-aware feature selection methods. You can find the full research paper here: TangledFeatures: Robust Feature Selection in Highly Correlated Spaces.
